Commit graph

72 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Justine Tunney
006c44ff5d
Update tests and CPU detection for Blink 2023-01-18 00:56:09 -08:00
Justine Tunney
e522aa3a07
Make more threading improvements
- ASAN memory morgue is now lockless
- Make C11 atomics header more portable
- Rewrote pthread keys support to be lockless
- Simplify Python's unicode table unpacking code
- Make crash report write(2) closer to being atomic
- Make it possible to strace/ftrace a single thread
- ASAN now checks nul-terminated strings fast and properly
- Windows fork() now restores TLS memory of calling thread
2022-11-01 23:28:26 -07:00
Justine Tunney
f7ff77d865
Make fixes and improvements
- Invent iso8601us() for faster timestamps
- Improve --strace descriptions of sigset_t
- Rebuild the Landlock Make bootstrap binary
- Introduce MODE=sysv for non-Windows builds
- Permit OFD fcntl() locks under pledge(flock)
- redbean can now protect your kernel from ddos
- Have vfork() fallback to sys_fork() not fork()
- Change kmalloc() to not die when out of memory
- Improve documentation for some termios functions
- Rewrite putenv() and friends to conform to POSIX
- Fix linenoise + strace verbosity issue on Windows
- Fix regressions in our ability to show backtraces
- Change redbean SetHeader() to no-op if value is nil
- Improve fcntl() so SQLite locks work in non-WAL mode
- Remove some unnecessary work during fork() on Windows
- Create redbean-based SSL reverse proxy for IPv4 TurfWar
- Fix ape/apeinstall.sh warning when using non-bash shells
- Add ProgramTrustedIp(), and IsTrustedIp() APIs to redbean
- Support $PWD, $UID, $GID, and $EUID in command interpreter
- Introduce experimental JTqFpD APE prefix for non-Windows builds
- Invent blackhole daemon for firewalling IP addresses via UNIX named socket
- Add ProgramTokenBucket(), AcquireToken(), and CountTokens() APIs to redbean
2022-10-19 07:19:19 -07:00
Justine Tunney
5af19b7eed
Make some foss compatibility improvements 2022-10-14 13:59:34 -07:00
Justine Tunney
0f89140882
Further improve cocmd interpreter 2022-10-12 10:44:54 -07:00
Justine Tunney
b41f91c658
Greatly expand system() shell code features
The cosmopolitan command interpreter now has 13 builtin commands,
variable support, support for ; / && / || syntax, asynchronous support,
and plenty of unit tests with bug fixes.

This change fixes a bug in posix_spawn() with null envp arg. strace
logging now uses atomic writes for scatter functions. Breaking change
renaming GetCpuCount() to _getcpucount(). TurfWar is now updated to use
the new token bucket algorithm. WIN32 affinity masks now inherit across
fork() and execve().
2022-10-11 21:30:31 -07:00
Justine Tunney
e557058ac8
Improve cosmo's conformance to libc-test
This change addresses various open source compatibility issues, so that
we pass 313/411 of the tests in https://github.com/jart/libc-test where
earlier today we were passing about 30/411 of them, due to header toil.
Please note that Glibc only passes 341/411 so 313 today is pretty good!

- Make the conformance of libc/isystem/ headers nearly perfect
- Import more of the remaining math library routines from Musl
- Fix inconsistencies with type signatures of calls like umask
- Write tests for getpriority/setpriority which work great now
- conform to `struct sockaddr *` on remaining socket functions
- Import a bunch of uninteresting stdlib functions e.g. rand48
- Introduce readdir_r, scandir, pthread_kill, sigsetjmp, etc..

Follow the instructions in our `tool/scripts/cosmocc` toolchain to run
these tests yourself. You use `make CC=cosmocc` on the test repository
2022-10-10 17:52:41 -07:00
Justine Tunney
5005f2e446
Rewrite brk() and sbrk()
This change reduces the .bss memory requirement for all executables by
O(64kb). The brk system calls are now fully tested and figured out and
might be useful for tiny programs that only target System Five.
2022-10-01 23:11:56 -07:00
Gavin Hayes
4c40c500b8
Add getgroups and setgroups (#619) 2022-09-18 02:48:53 -07:00
Justine Tunney
994e1f4386
Improve pthread_join()
Since we're now on Windows 8, we can have clone() work as advertised on
Windows, where it sends a futex wake to the child tid. It's also likely
we no longer need to work around thread flakes on OpenBSD, in _wait0().
2022-09-16 14:02:06 -07:00
Justine Tunney
1ad2f530f9
Add script.com and whois.com courtesy of FreeBSD 2022-09-13 20:26:13 -07:00
Justine Tunney
6f7d0cb1c3
Pay off more technical debt
This makes breaking changes to add underscores to many non-standard
function names provided by the c library. MODE=tiny is now tinier and
we now use smaller locks that are better for tiny apps in this mode.
Some headers have been renamed to be in the same folder as the build
package, so it'll be easier to know which build dependency is needed.
Certain old misguided interfaces have been removed. Intel intrinsics
headers are now listed in libc/isystem (but not in the amalgamation)
to help further improve open source compatibility. Header complexity
has also been reduced. Lastly, more shell scripts are now available.
2022-09-12 23:36:56 -07:00
Justine Tunney
dbf12c30b0
Make more compatibility improvements 2022-09-06 12:36:34 -07:00
Justine Tunney
c5c4dfcd21 Improve quality of raise(), abort(), and tkill()
This change fixes a nasty bug where SIG_IGN and SIG_DFL weren't working
as advertised on BSDs. This change also fixes the tkill() definition on
MacOS so it maps to __pthread_kill().
2022-09-03 20:17:54 -07:00
Justine Tunney
ead3fc2b31 Fix Landlock Make so it can read pattern rule vars
It turned out that specifying all SRCS and INCS as dependencies on the
pattern rules for all headers, caused `make` memory usage to skyrocket
from 40mb ot 160mb. This change also reduces the build graph another 4%.
2022-08-13 17:23:05 -07:00
Justine Tunney
0277d7d6e9 Rewrite Linux pledge() code so it can be a payload
It's now possible to build our pledge() polyfill as a dynamic shared
object that can be injected into a glibc executable using LD_PRELOAD
2022-08-08 11:41:08 -07:00
Justine Tunney
5546559034 Improve pledge() usability and consistency
- We now kill the program on violations like OpenBSD
- We now print a message explaining which promise is needed
- This change also fixes a linkage bug with thread local storage
- Your sigaction() handlers should now be more thread safe

A new `__pledge_mode` global has been introduced to make pledge() more
customizable on Linux. For example:

    __attribute__((__constructor__)) static void init(void) {
      __pledge_mode = SECCOMP_RET_ERRNO | EPERM;
    }

Can be used to restore our old permissive pledge() behavior.
2022-08-07 16:18:33 -07:00
Justine Tunney
13c1c45075 Make some last minute improvements to make.com 2022-08-07 05:59:53 -07:00
Justine Tunney
a8cf0f7e89 Add more missing libc functionality 2022-08-06 10:50:51 -07:00
Justine Tunney
cf93ecbbb2 Prove that Makefile is fully defined
The whole repository is now buildable with GNU Make Landlock sandboxing.
This proves that no Makefile targets exist which touch files other than
their declared prerequisites. In order to do this, we had to:

  1. Stop code morphing GCC output in package.com and instead run a
     newly introduced FIXUPOBJ.COM command after GCC invocations.

  2. Disable all the crumby Python unit tests that do things like create
     files in the current directory, or rename() files between folders.
     This ended up being a lot of tests, but most of them are still ok.

  3. Introduce an .UNSANDBOXED variable to GNU Make to disable Landlock.
     We currently only do this for things like `make tags`.

  4. This change deletes some GNU Make code that was preventing the
     execve() optimization from working. This means it should no longer
     be necessary in most cases for command invocations to be indirected
     through the cocmd interpreter.

  5. Missing dependencies had to be declared in certain places, in cases
     where they couldn't be automatically determined by MKDEPS.COM

  6. The libcxx header situation has finally been tamed. One of the
     things that makes this difficult is MKDEPS.COM only wants to
     consider the first 64kb of a file, in order to go fast. But libcxx
     likes to have #include lines buried after huge documentation.

  7. An .UNVEIL variable has been introduced to GNU Make just in case
     we ever wish to explicitly specify additional things that need to
     be whitelisted which aren't strictly prerequisites. This works in
     a manner similar to the recently introduced .EXTRA_PREREQS feature.

There's now a new build/bootstrap/make.com prebuilt binary available. It
should no longer be possible to write invalid Makefile code.
2022-08-06 04:05:08 -07:00
Justine Tunney
e98514cdb7 Plug a hole in pledge()
Günther Noack points out that O_RDONLY|O_TRUNC will modify a file.
2022-07-24 23:41:59 -07:00
Justine Tunney
3d2cf95af1 Remove malloc() dependency on pledge() / unveil()
This change also fixes a bug with gettid() being incorrect after fork().
We now implement the ENOENT behavior for getauxval(). The getuid() etc.
system calls are now faster too. Plus issetugid() will work on BSDs.
2022-07-24 21:51:37 -07:00
Justine Tunney
5f4f6b0e69 Make _Thread_local work across platforms
We now rewrite the binary image at runtime on Windows and XNU to change
mov %fs:0,%reg instructions to use %gs instead. There's also simpler
threading API introduced by this change and it's called _spawn() and
_join(), which has replaced most clone() usage.
2022-07-10 04:01:17 -07:00
Justine Tunney
853b6c3864 Improve system calls
- Wrap clock_getres()
- Wrap sched_setscheduler()
- Make sleep() api conformant
- Polyfill sleep() using select()
- Improve clock_gettime() polyfill
- Make nanosleep() POSIX conformant
- Slightly improve some DNS functions
- Further strengthen pledge() sandboxing
- Improve rounding of timeval / timespec
- Allow layering of pledge() calls on Linux
- Polyfill sched_yield() using select() on XNU
- Delete more system constants we probably don't need
2022-07-08 06:42:03 -07:00
Justine Tunney
3c92adfd6e Strengthen the pledge() polyfill 2022-06-27 13:02:17 -07:00
Justine Tunney
4ddfc47d6e Make some more fixups 2022-06-12 09:37:17 -07:00
Justine Tunney
c6d8e516b2 Print warning when microbenchmarking w/ powersave
RDTSC on Linux has so much jitter when the CPU is in powersave mode
causing things like microbenchmarks to have a 1000% margin of error
2022-06-10 21:07:03 -07:00
Justine Tunney
de5de19004 Make improvements
- Document redbean's argon2 module
- Fix regressions in cthreads library
- Make testlib work better with threads
- Give the cthreads library lots of love
- Remove some of the stdio assembly code
- Implement getloadavg() across platforms
- Code size optimizations for errnos, etc.
- Only check for signals in main thread on Windows
- Make errnos for dup2 / dup3 consistent with posix

This change also fixes a bug in the argon2 module, where the NUL
terminator was being included in the hash encoded ascii string. This
shouldn't require any database migrations to folks who found this module
and productionized it, since the argon2 library treats it as a c string.
2022-05-28 00:28:09 -07:00
Justine Tunney
ec2cb88058 Make fixes and improvements
- Document more compiler flags
- Expose new __print_maps() api
- Better overflow checking in mmap()
- Improve the shell example somewhat
- Fix minor runtime bugs regarding stacks
- Make kill() on fork()+execve()'d children work
- Support CLONE_CHILD_CLEARTID for proper joining
- Fix recent possible deadlock regression with --ftrace
2022-05-19 16:57:49 -07:00
Justine Tunney
9208c83f7a Make some systemic improvements
- add vdso dump utility
- tests now log stack usage
- rename g_ftrace to __ftrace
- make internal spinlocks go faster
- add conformant c11 atomics library
- function tracing now logs stack usage
- make function call tracing thread safe
- add -X unsecure (no ssl) mode to redbean
- munmap() has more consistent behavior now
- pacify fsync() calls on python unit tests
- make --strace flag work better in redbean
- start minimizing and documenting compiler flags
2022-05-18 16:52:36 -07:00
Justine Tunney
55de4ca6b5 Support thread local storage 2022-05-16 13:20:08 -07:00
Justine Tunney
47b3274665 Make improvements
- Add rusage to redbean Lua API
- Add more redbean documentation
- Add pledge() to redbean Lua API
- Polyfill OpenBSD pledge() for Linux
- Increase PATH_MAX limit to 1024 characters
- Untrack sibling processes after fork() on Windows
2022-04-28 09:57:07 -07:00
Justine Tunney
d57b81aac7 Make improvements
- Add GetCpuCount() API to redbean
- Add unix.gmtime() API to redbean
- Add unix.readlink() API to redbean
- Add unix.localtime() API to redbean
- Perfect the new redbean UNIX module APIs
- Integrate with Linux clock_gettime() vDSO
- Run Lua garbage collector when malloc() fails
- Fix another regression quirk with linenoise repl
- Fix GetProgramExecutableName() for systemwide installs
- Fix a build flake with test/libc/mem/test.mk SRCS list
2022-04-26 16:46:15 -07:00
Justine Tunney
2046c0d2ae Make improvements
- Expand redbean UNIX module
- Expand redbean documentation
- Ensure Lua copyright is embedded in binary
- Increase the PATH_MAX limit especially on NT
- Use column major sorting for linenoise completions
- Fix some suboptimalities in redbean's new UNIX API
- Figured out right flags for Multics newline in raw mode
2022-04-24 10:06:05 -07:00
Justine Tunney
2f56ebfe78 Do code cleanup use duff device linenoise i/o 2022-04-22 18:56:52 -07:00
Justine Tunney
5a132f9652 Add seccomp bpf sandboxing to redbean
It's now possible to pass the `-S` or `-SS` flags to sandbox redbean
worker proecsses after they've been forked. The first `-S` flag is
intended to be a permissive builtin policy that limits system calls to
only that which the various parts of redbean serving need. The second
`-SS` flag is intended to be more restrictive, preventing things like
the Lua extensions you download off the web from using the HTTP client
or sockets APIs. In upcoming changes you'll be able to implement your
own Berkeley Packet Filter sandbox programs and load them via Lua.
2022-04-18 08:54:42 -07:00
Justine Tunney
7166679620 Fix bugs and add security features to redbean
- Fix a regression with the previous change that broke redbean
- Add chroot(), resource limit, seccomp, and other stuff to redbean
- Write lots and lots of documentation
- Iron out more system call issues
2022-04-18 00:01:26 -07:00
Justine Tunney
dc0ea6640e Fix bugs with recent change
This change makes further effort towards improving our poll()
implementation on the New Technology. The stdin worker didn't work out
so well for Python so it's not being used for now. System call tracing
with the --strace flag should now be less noisy now on Windows unless
you modify the strace.internal.h defines to turn on some optional ones
that are most useful for debugging the system call wrappers.
2022-04-16 10:40:23 -07:00
Justine Tunney
23b72eb617 Add support for symbol table in .com files
This change fixes minor bugs and adds a feature, which lets us store the
ELF symbol table, inside the ZIP directory. We use the path /zip/.symtab
which can be safely removed using a zip editing tool, to make the binary
smaller after compilation. This supplements the existing method of using
a separate .com.dbg file, which is still supported. The intent is people
don't always know that it's a good idea to download the debug file. It's
not great having someone's first experience be a crash report, that only
has numbers rather than symbols. This will help fix that!
2022-03-23 06:34:46 -07:00
Justine Tunney
0cb6b6ff4b Get Redbean fork() working on the New Technology
Now that we have understandable system call tracing on Windows, this
change rewrites many of the polyfill internals for that platform, to
help things get closer to tip top shape. Support for complex forking
scenarios had been in a regressed state for quite some time. Now, it
works! Subsequent changes should be able to address the performance.
2022-03-20 08:01:14 -07:00
Justine Tunney
b45d50b690 Make improvements
- Fix build flakes
- Polyfill SIGWINCH on Windows
- Fix an execve issue on Windows
- Make strerror show more information
- Improve cmd.exe setup/teardown on Windows
- Support bracketed paste mode in Blinkenlights
- Show keyboard shortcuts in Blinkenlights status bar
- Fixed copy_file_range() and copyfile() w/ zip filesystem
- Size optimize GetDosArgv() to keep life.com 12kb in size
- Improve Blinkenlights ability to load weird ELF executables
- Fix program_executable_name and add GetInterpreterExecutableName
- Make Python in tiny mode fail better if docstrings are requested
- Update Python test exclusions in tiny* modes such as tinylinux
- Add bulletproof unbreakable kprintf() troubleshooting function
- Remove "oldskool" keyword from ape.S for virus scanners
- Fix issue that caused backtraces to not print sometimes
- Improve Blinkenlights serial uart character i/o
- Make clock_gettime() not clobber errno on xnu
- Improve sha256 cpuid check for old computers
- Integrate some bestline linenoise fixes
- Show runit process names better in htop
- Remove SIGPIPE from ShowCrashReports()
- Make realpath() not clobber errno
- Avoid attaching GDB on non-Linux
- Improve img.com example
2022-03-16 13:40:10 -07:00
Justine Tunney
67b5200a0b Add MODE=optlinux build mode (#141) 2021-10-14 19:36:49 -07:00
Justine Tunney
226aaf3547 Improve memory safety
This commit makes numerous refinements to cosmopolitan memory handling.

The default stack size has been reduced from 2mb to 128kb. A new macro
is now provided so you can easily reconfigure the stack size to be any
value you want. Work around the breaking change by adding to your main:

    STATIC_STACK_SIZE(0x00200000);  // 2mb stack

If you're not sure how much stack you need, then you can use:

    STATIC_YOINK("stack_usage_logging");

After which you can `sort -nr o/$MODE/stack.log`. Based on the unit test
suite, nothing in the Cosmopolitan repository (except for Python) needs
a stack size greater than 30kb. There are also new macros for detecting
the size and address of the stack at runtime, e.g. GetStackAddr(). We
also now support sigaltstack() so if you want to see nice looking crash
reports whenever a stack overflow happens, you can put this in main():

    ShowCrashReports();

Under `make MODE=dbg` and `make MODE=asan` the unit testing framework
will now automatically print backtraces of memory allocations when
things like memory leaks happen. Bugs are now fixed in ASAN global
variable overrun detection. The memtrack and asan runtimes also handle
edge cases now. The new tools helped to identify a few memory leaks,
which are fixed by this change.

This change should fix an issue reported in #288 with ARG_MAX limits.
Fixing this doubled the performance of MKDEPS.COM and AR.COM yet again.
2021-10-13 17:27:13 -07:00
Gautham
d852640a1e
Add Python ftrace contextmanager (#285) 2021-10-13 11:00:25 -07:00
Justine Tunney
725f4d79f6 Apply fixes and speedups 2021-10-04 03:23:31 -07:00
Justine Tunney
39bf41f4eb Make numerous improvements
- Python static hello world now 1.8mb
- Python static fully loaded now 10mb
- Python HTTPS client now uses MbedTLS
- Python REPL now completes import stmts
- Increase stack size for Python for now
- Begin synthesizing posixpath and ntpath
- Restore Python \N{UNICODE NAME} support
- Restore Python NFKD symbol normalization
- Add optimized code path for Intel SHA-NI
- Get more Python unit tests passing faster
- Get Python help() pagination working on NT
- Python hashlib now supports MbedTLS PBKDF2
- Make memcpy/memmove/memcmp/bcmp/etc. faster
- Add Mersenne Twister and Vigna to LIBC_RAND
- Provide privileged __printf() for error code
- Fix zipos opendir() so that it reports ENOTDIR
- Add basic chmod() implementation for Windows NT
- Add Cosmo's best functions to Python cosmo module
- Pin function trace indent depth to that of caller
- Show memory diagram on invalid access in MODE=dbg
- Differentiate stack overflow on crash in MODE=dbg
- Add stb_truetype and tools for analyzing font files
- Upgrade to UNICODE 13 and reduce its binary footprint
- COMPILE.COM now logs resource usage of build commands
- Start implementing basic poll() support on bare metal
- Set getauxval(AT_EXECFN) to GetModuleFileName() on NT
- Add descriptions to strerror() in non-TINY build modes
- Add COUNTBRANCH() macro to help with micro-optimizations
- Make error / backtrace / asan / memory code more unbreakable
- Add fast perfect C implementation of μ-Law and a-Law audio codecs
- Make strtol() functions consistent with other libc implementations
- Improve Linenoise implementation (see also github.com/jart/bestline)
- COMPILE.COM now suppresses stdout/stderr of successful build commands
2021-09-28 01:52:34 -07:00
Justine Tunney
00611e9b06 Improve ZIP filesystem and change its prefix
The ZIP filesystem has a breaking change. You now need to use /zip/ to
open() / opendir() / etc. assets within the ZIP structure of your APE
binary, instead of the previous convention of using zip: or zip! URIs.
This is needed because Python likes to use absolute paths, and having
ZIP paths encoded like URIs simply broke too many things.

Many more system calls have been updated to be able to operate on ZIP
files and file descriptors. In particular fcntl() and ioctl() since
Python would do things like ask if a ZIP file is a terminal and get
confused when the old implementation mistakenly said yes, because the
fastest way to guarantee native file descriptors is to dup(2). This
change also improves the async signal safety of zipos and ensures it
doesn't maintain any open file descriptors beyond that which the user
has opened.

This change makes a lot of progress towards adding magic numbers that
are specific to platforms other than Linux. The philosophy here is that,
if you use an operating system like FreeBSD, then you should be able to
take advantage of FreeBSD exclusive features, even if we don't polyfill
them on other platforms. For example, you can now open() a file with the
O_VERIFY flag. If your program runs on other platforms, then Cosmo will
automatically set O_VERIFY to zero. This lets you safely use it without
the need for #ifdef or ifstatements which detract from readability.

One of the blindspots of the ASAN memory hardening we use to offer Rust
like assurances has always been that memory passed to the kernel via
system calls (e.g. writev) can't be checked automatically since the
kernel wasn't built with MODE=asan. This change makes more progress
ensuring that each system call will verify the soundness of memory
before it's passed to the kernel. The code for doing these checks is
fast, particularly for buffers, where it can verify 64 bytes a cycle.

- Correct O_LOOP definition on NT
- Introduce program_executable_name
- Add ASAN guards to more system calls
- Improve termios compatibility with BSDs
- Fix bug in Windows auxiliary value encoding
- Add BSD and XNU specific errnos and open flags
- Add check to ensure build doesn't talk to internet
2021-08-22 01:11:53 -07:00
Justine Tunney
8af197560e Improve Libc by making Python work even better
Actually Portable Python is now outperforming the Python binaries
that come bundled with Linux distros, at things like HTTP serving.
You can now have a fully featured Python install in just one .com
file that runs on six operating systems and is about 10mb in size.
With tuning, the tiniest is ~1mb. We've got most of the libraries
working, including pysqlite, and the repl now feels very pleasant.
The things you can't do quite yet are: threads and shared objects
but that can happen in the future, if the community falls in love
with this project and wants to see it developed further. Changes:

- Add siginterrupt()
- Add sqlite3 to Python
- Add issymlink() helper
- Make GetZipCdir() faster
- Add tgamma() and finite()
- Add legacy function lutimes()
- Add readlink() and realpath()
- Use heap allocations when appropriate
- Reorganize Python into two-stage build
- Save Lua / Python shell history to dotfile
- Integrate Python Lib embedding into linkage
- Make isregularfile() and isdirectory() go faster
- Make Python shell auto-completion work perfectly
- Make crash reports work better if changed directory
- Fix Python+NT open() / access() flag overflow error
- Disable Python tests relating to \N{LONG NAME} syntax
- Have Python REPL copyright() show all notice embeddings

The biggest technical challenge at the moment is working around
when Python tries to be too clever about filenames.
2021-08-18 22:16:23 -07:00
Justine Tunney
f3e28aa192 Make SSL handshakes much faster
This change boosts SSL handshake performance from 2,627 to ~10,000 per
second which is the same level of performance as NGINX at establishing
secure connections. That's impressive if we consider that redbean is a
forking frontend application server. This was accomplished by:

  1. Enabling either SSL session caching or SSL tickets. We choose to
     use tickets since they reduce network round trips too and that's
     a more important metric than wrk'ing localhost.

  2. Fixing mbedtls_mpi_sub_abs() which is the most frequently called
     function. It's called about 12,000 times during an SSL handshake
     since it's the basis of most arithmetic operations like addition
     and for some strange reason it was designed to make two needless
     copies in addition to calling malloc and free. That's now fixed.

  3. Improving TLS output buffering during the SSL handshake only, so
     that only a single is write and read system call is needed until
     blocking on the ping pong.

redbean will now do a better job wiping sensitive memory from a child
process as soon as it's not needed. The nice thing about fork is it's
much faster than reverse proxying so the goal is to use the different
address spaces along with setuid() to minimize the risk that a server
key will be compromised in the event that application code is hacked.
2021-07-11 23:17:47 -07:00
Justine Tunney
dc6d11a031 Improve performance of printf functions 2021-04-24 13:58:50 -07:00