Merge pull request #373 from moorereason/feature/multipart

Add multipart form data support
This commit is contained in:
Adnan Hajdarević 2019-12-26 12:46:31 +01:00 committed by GitHub
commit f38dfbbf78
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG key ID: 4AEE18F83AFDEB23
6 changed files with 251 additions and 44 deletions

View file

@ -77,6 +77,18 @@ By performing a simple HTTP GET or POST request to that endpoint, your specified
However, hook defined like that could pose a security threat to your system, because anyone who knows your endpoint, can send a request and execute your command. To prevent that, you can use the `"trigger-rule"` property for your hook, to specify the exact circumstances under which the hook would be triggered. For example, you can use them to add a secret that you must supply as a parameter in order to successfully trigger the hook. Please check out the [Hook rules page](docs/Hook-Rules.md) for detailed list of available rules and their usage. However, hook defined like that could pose a security threat to your system, because anyone who knows your endpoint, can send a request and execute your command. To prevent that, you can use the `"trigger-rule"` property for your hook, to specify the exact circumstances under which the hook would be triggered. For example, you can use them to add a secret that you must supply as a parameter in order to successfully trigger the hook. Please check out the [Hook rules page](docs/Hook-Rules.md) for detailed list of available rules and their usage.
## Multipart Form Data
[webhook][w] provides limited support the parsing of multipart form data.
Multipart form data can contain two types of parts: values and files.
All form _values_ are automatically added to the `payload` scope.
Use the `parse-parameters-as-json` settings to parse a given value as JSON.
All files are ignored unless they match one of the following criteria:
1. The `Content-Type` header is `application/json`.
1. The part is named in the `parse-parameters-as-json` setting.
In either case, the given file part will be parsed as JSON and added to the `payload` map.
## Templates ## Templates
[webhook][w] can parse the `hooks.json` input file as a Go template when given the `-template` [CLI parameter](docs/Webhook-Parameters.md). See the [Templates page](docs/Templates.md) for more details on template usage. [webhook][w] can parse the `hooks.json` input file as a Go template when given the `-template` [CLI parameter](docs/Webhook-Parameters.md). See the [Templates page](docs/Templates.md) for more details on template usage.

View file

@ -287,12 +287,12 @@ __Not recommended in production due to low security__
] ]
``` ```
# JIRA Webhooks ## JIRA Webhooks
[Guide by @perfecto25](https://sites.google.com/site/mrxpalmeiras/notes/jira-webhooks) [Guide by @perfecto25](https://sites.google.com/site/mrxpalmeiras/notes/jira-webhooks)
# Pass File-to-command sample ## Pass File-to-command sample
## Webhook configuration ### Webhook configuration
<pre> <pre>
[ [
@ -315,7 +315,7 @@ __Not recommended in production due to low security__
] ]
</pre> </pre>
## Sample client usage ### Sample client usage
Store the following file as `testRequest.json`. Store the following file as `testRequest.json`.
@ -474,3 +474,47 @@ Given the following payload:
} }
] ]
``` ```
## Multipart Form Data
Example of a [Plex Media Server webhook](https://support.plex.tv/articles/115002267687-webhooks/).
The Plex Media Server will send two parts: payload and thumb.
We only care about the payload part.
```json
[
{
"id": "plex",
"execute-command": "play-command.sh",
"parse-parameters-as-json": [
{
"source": "payload",
"name": "payload"
}
],
"trigger-rule":
{
"match":
{
"type": "value",
"parameter": {
"source": "payload",
"name": "payload.event"
},
"value": "media.play"
}
}
}
]
```
Each part of a multipart form data body will have a `Content-Disposition` header.
Some example headers:
```
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="payload"
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="thumb"; filename="thumb.jpg"
```
We key off of the `name` attribute in the `Content-Disposition` value.

View file

@ -167,6 +167,30 @@
], ],
} }
}, },
{
"id": "plex",
"execute-command": "{{ .Hookecho }}",
"command-working-directory": "/",
"response-message": "success",
"parse-parameters-as-json": [
{
"source": "payload",
"name": "payload"
}
],
"trigger-rule":
{
"match":
{
"type": "value",
"parameter": {
"source": "payload",
"name": "payload.event"
},
"value": "media.play"
}
}
},
{ {
"id": "capture-command-output-on-success-not-by-default", "id": "capture-command-output-on-success-not-by-default",
"pass-arguments-to-command": [ "pass-arguments-to-command": [

View file

@ -95,6 +95,21 @@
name: "app.messages.message.#text" name: "app.messages.message.#text"
value: "Hello!!" value: "Hello!!"
- id: plex
trigger-rule:
match:
type: value
parameter:
source: payload
name: payload.event
value: media.play
parse-parameters-as-json:
- source: payload
name: payload
execute-command: '{{ .Hookecho }}'
response-message: success
command-working-directory: /
- id: capture-command-output-on-success-not-by-default - id: capture-command-output-on-success-not-by-default
pass-arguments-to-command: pass-arguments-to-command:
- source: string - source: string

View file

@ -46,6 +46,7 @@ var (
tlsCipherSuites = flag.String("cipher-suites", "", "comma-separated list of supported TLS cipher suites") tlsCipherSuites = flag.String("cipher-suites", "", "comma-separated list of supported TLS cipher suites")
useXRequestID = flag.Bool("x-request-id", false, "use X-Request-Id header, if present, as request ID") useXRequestID = flag.Bool("x-request-id", false, "use X-Request-Id header, if present, as request ID")
xRequestIDLimit = flag.Int("x-request-id-limit", 0, "truncate X-Request-Id header to limit; default no limit") xRequestIDLimit = flag.Int("x-request-id-limit", 0, "truncate X-Request-Id header to limit; default no limit")
maxMultipartMem = flag.Int64("max-multipart-mem", 1<<20, "maximum memory in bytes for parsing multipart form data before disk caching")
responseHeaders hook.ResponseHeaders responseHeaders hook.ResponseHeaders
hooksFiles hook.HooksFiles hooksFiles hook.HooksFiles
@ -230,9 +231,24 @@ func hookHandler(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request) {
if matchedHook := matchLoadedHook(id); matchedHook != nil { if matchedHook := matchLoadedHook(id); matchedHook != nil {
log.Printf("[%s] %s got matched\n", rid, id) log.Printf("[%s] %s got matched\n", rid, id)
body, err := ioutil.ReadAll(r.Body) var (
if err != nil { body []byte
log.Printf("[%s] error reading the request body. %+v\n", rid, err) err error
)
// set contentType to IncomingPayloadContentType or header value
contentType := r.Header.Get("Content-Type")
if len(matchedHook.IncomingPayloadContentType) != 0 {
contentType = matchedHook.IncomingPayloadContentType
}
isMultipart := strings.HasPrefix(contentType, "multipart/form-data;")
if !isMultipart {
body, err = ioutil.ReadAll(r.Body)
if err != nil {
log.Printf("[%s] error reading the request body: %+v\n", rid, err)
}
} }
// parse headers // parse headers
@ -244,21 +260,16 @@ func hookHandler(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request) {
// parse body // parse body
var payload map[string]interface{} var payload map[string]interface{}
// set contentType to IncomingPayloadContentType or header value
contentType := r.Header.Get("Content-Type")
if len(matchedHook.IncomingPayloadContentType) != 0 {
contentType = matchedHook.IncomingPayloadContentType
}
switch { switch {
case strings.Contains(contentType, "json"): case strings.Contains(contentType, "json"):
decoder := json.NewDecoder(strings.NewReader(string(body))) decoder := json.NewDecoder(bytes.NewReader(body))
decoder.UseNumber() decoder.UseNumber()
err := decoder.Decode(&payload) err := decoder.Decode(&payload)
if err != nil { if err != nil {
log.Printf("[%s] error parsing JSON payload %+v\n", rid, err) log.Printf("[%s] error parsing JSON payload %+v\n", rid, err)
} }
case strings.Contains(contentType, "x-www-form-urlencoded"): case strings.Contains(contentType, "x-www-form-urlencoded"):
fd, err := url.ParseQuery(string(body)) fd, err := url.ParseQuery(string(body))
if err != nil { if err != nil {
@ -266,11 +277,87 @@ func hookHandler(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request) {
} else { } else {
payload = valuesToMap(fd) payload = valuesToMap(fd)
} }
case strings.Contains(contentType, "xml"): case strings.Contains(contentType, "xml"):
payload, err = mxj.NewMapXmlReader(bytes.NewReader(body)) payload, err = mxj.NewMapXmlReader(bytes.NewReader(body))
if err != nil { if err != nil {
log.Printf("[%s] error parsing XML payload: %+v\n", rid, err) log.Printf("[%s] error parsing XML payload: %+v\n", rid, err)
} }
case isMultipart:
err = r.ParseMultipartForm(*maxMultipartMem)
if err != nil {
msg := fmt.Sprintf("[%s] error parsing multipart form: %+v\n", rid, err)
log.Println(msg)
w.WriteHeader(http.StatusInternalServerError)
fmt.Fprint(w, "Error occurred while parsing multipart form.")
return
}
for k, v := range r.MultipartForm.Value {
log.Printf("[%s] found multipart form value %q", rid, k)
if payload == nil {
payload = make(map[string]interface{})
}
// TODO(moorereason): support duplicate, named values
payload[k] = v[0]
}
for k, v := range r.MultipartForm.File {
// Force parsing as JSON regardless of Content-Type.
var parseAsJSON bool
for _, j := range matchedHook.JSONStringParameters {
if j.Source == "payload" && j.Name == k {
parseAsJSON = true
break
}
}
// TODO(moorereason): we need to support multiple parts
// with the same name instead of just processing the first
// one. Will need #215 resolved first.
// MIME encoding can contain duplicate headers, so check them
// all.
if !parseAsJSON && len(v[0].Header["Content-Type"]) > 0 {
for _, j := range v[0].Header["Content-Type"] {
if j == "application/json" {
parseAsJSON = true
break
}
}
}
if parseAsJSON {
log.Printf("[%s] parsing multipart form file %q as JSON\n", rid, k)
f, err := v[0].Open()
if err != nil {
msg := fmt.Sprintf("[%s] error parsing multipart form file: %+v\n", rid, err)
log.Println(msg)
w.WriteHeader(http.StatusInternalServerError)
fmt.Fprint(w, "Error occurred while parsing multipart form file.")
return
}
decoder := json.NewDecoder(f)
decoder.UseNumber()
var part map[string]interface{}
err = decoder.Decode(&part)
if err != nil {
log.Printf("[%s] error parsing JSON payload file: %+v\n", rid, err)
}
if payload == nil {
payload = make(map[string]interface{})
}
payload[k] = part
}
}
default: default:
log.Printf("[%s] error parsing body payload due to unsupported content type header: %s\n", rid, contentType) log.Printf("[%s] error parsing body payload due to unsupported content type header: %s\n", rid, contentType)
} }

View file

@ -75,7 +75,7 @@ func TestWebhook(t *testing.T) {
defer cleanupConfigFn() defer cleanupConfigFn()
for _, tt := range hookHandlerTests { for _, tt := range hookHandlerTests {
t.Run(tt.desc, func(t *testing.T) { t.Run(tt.desc+"@"+hookTmpl, func(t *testing.T) {
ip, port := serverAddress(t) ip, port := serverAddress(t)
args := []string{fmt.Sprintf("-hooks=%s", configPath), fmt.Sprintf("-ip=%s", ip), fmt.Sprintf("-port=%s", port), "-verbose"} args := []string{fmt.Sprintf("-hooks=%s", configPath), fmt.Sprintf("-ip=%s", ip), fmt.Sprintf("-port=%s", port), "-verbose"}
@ -106,13 +106,7 @@ func TestWebhook(t *testing.T) {
var res *http.Response var res *http.Response
if tt.urlencoded == true { req.Header.Add("Content-Type", tt.contentType)
req.Header.Add("Content-Type", "application/x-www-form-urlencoded")
} else {
if req.Header.Get("Content-Type") == "" {
req.Header.Add("Content-Type", "application/json")
}
}
client := &http.Client{} client := &http.Client{}
res, err = client.Do(req) res, err = client.Do(req)
@ -127,7 +121,7 @@ func TestWebhook(t *testing.T) {
} }
if res.StatusCode != tt.respStatus || string(body) != tt.respBody { if res.StatusCode != tt.respStatus || string(body) != tt.respBody {
t.Errorf("failed %q (id: %s):\nexpected status: %#v, response: %s\ngot status: %#v, response: %s", tt.desc, tt.id, tt.respStatus, tt.respBody, res.StatusCode, body) t.Errorf("failed %q (id: %s):\nexpected status: %#v, response: %s\ngot status: %#v, response: %s\ncommand output:\n%s\n", tt.desc, tt.id, tt.respStatus, tt.respBody, res.StatusCode, body, b)
} }
if tt.logMatch == "" { if tt.logMatch == "" {
@ -293,11 +287,11 @@ func webhookEnv() (env []string) {
} }
var hookHandlerTests = []struct { var hookHandlerTests = []struct {
desc string desc string
id string id string
headers map[string]string headers map[string]string
body string contentType string
urlencoded bool body string
respStatus int respStatus int
respBody string respBody string
@ -307,6 +301,7 @@ var hookHandlerTests = []struct {
"github", "github",
"github", "github",
map[string]string{"X-Hub-Signature": "f68df0375d7b03e3eb29b4cf9f9ec12e08f42ff8"}, map[string]string{"X-Hub-Signature": "f68df0375d7b03e3eb29b4cf9f9ec12e08f42ff8"},
"application/json",
`{ `{
"after":"1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb", "after":"1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb",
"before":"17c497ccc7cca9c2f735aa07e9e3813060ce9a6a", "before":"17c497ccc7cca9c2f735aa07e9e3813060ce9a6a",
@ -451,7 +446,6 @@ var hookHandlerTests = []struct {
"watchers":1 "watchers":1
} }
}`, }`,
false,
http.StatusOK, http.StatusOK,
`arg: 1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb lolwut@noway.biz `arg: 1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb lolwut@noway.biz
env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00 env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
@ -462,8 +456,8 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
"bitbucket", // bitbucket sends their payload using uriencoded params. "bitbucket", // bitbucket sends their payload using uriencoded params.
"bitbucket", "bitbucket",
nil, nil,
"application/x-www-form-urlencoded",
`payload={"canon_url": "https://bitbucket.org","commits": [{"author": "marcus","branch": "master","files": [{"file": "somefile.py","type": "modified"}],"message": "Added some more things to somefile.py\n","node": "620ade18607a","parents": ["702c70160afc"],"raw_author": "Marcus Bertrand <marcus@somedomain.com>","raw_node": "620ade18607ac42d872b568bb92acaa9a28620e9","revision": null,"size": -1,"timestamp": "2012-05-30 05:58:56","utctimestamp": "2014-11-07 15:19:02+00:00"}],"repository": {"absolute_url": "/webhook/testing/","fork": false,"is_private": true,"name": "Project X","owner": "marcus","scm": "git","slug": "project-x","website": "https://atlassian.com/"},"user": "marcus"}`, `payload={"canon_url": "https://bitbucket.org","commits": [{"author": "marcus","branch": "master","files": [{"file": "somefile.py","type": "modified"}],"message": "Added some more things to somefile.py\n","node": "620ade18607a","parents": ["702c70160afc"],"raw_author": "Marcus Bertrand <marcus@somedomain.com>","raw_node": "620ade18607ac42d872b568bb92acaa9a28620e9","revision": null,"size": -1,"timestamp": "2012-05-30 05:58:56","utctimestamp": "2014-11-07 15:19:02+00:00"}],"repository": {"absolute_url": "/webhook/testing/","fork": false,"is_private": true,"name": "Project X","owner": "marcus","scm": "git","slug": "project-x","website": "https://atlassian.com/"},"user": "marcus"}`,
true,
http.StatusOK, http.StatusOK,
`success`, `success`,
``, ``,
@ -472,6 +466,7 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
"gitlab", "gitlab",
"gitlab", "gitlab",
map[string]string{"X-Gitlab-Event": "Push Hook"}, map[string]string{"X-Gitlab-Event": "Push Hook"},
"application/json",
`{ `{
"object_kind": "push", "object_kind": "push",
"before": "95790bf891e76fee5e1747ab589903a6a1f80f22", "before": "95790bf891e76fee5e1747ab589903a6a1f80f22",
@ -514,7 +509,6 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
], ],
"total_commits_count": 4 "total_commits_count": 4
}`, }`,
false,
http.StatusOK, http.StatusOK,
`arg: b6568db1bc1dcd7f8b4d5a946b0b91f9dacd7327 John Smith john@example.com `arg: b6568db1bc1dcd7f8b4d5a946b0b91f9dacd7327 John Smith john@example.com
`, `,
@ -524,6 +518,7 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
"xml", "xml",
"xml", "xml",
map[string]string{"Content-Type": "application/xml"}, map[string]string{"Content-Type": "application/xml"},
"application/xml",
`<app> `<app>
<users> <users>
<user id="1" name="Jeff" /> <user id="1" name="Jeff" />
@ -533,15 +528,46 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
<message id="1" from_user="1" to_user="2">Hello!!</message> <message id="1" from_user="1" to_user="2">Hello!!</message>
</messages> </messages>
</app>`, </app>`,
false,
http.StatusOK, http.StatusOK,
`success`, `success`,
``, ``,
}, },
{
"multipart",
"plex",
nil,
"multipart/form-data; boundary=xxx",
`--xxx
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="payload"
{
"event": "media.play",
"user": true,
"owner": true,
"Account": {
"id": 1,
"thumb": "https://plex.tv/users/1022b120ffbaa/avatar?c=1465525047",
"title": "elan"
}
}
--xxx
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="thumb"; filename="thumb.jpg"
Content-Type: application/octet-stream
Content-Transfer-Encoding: binary
binary data
--xxx--`,
http.StatusOK,
`success`,
``,
},
{ {
"missing-cmd-arg", // missing head_commit.author.email "missing-cmd-arg", // missing head_commit.author.email
"github", "github",
map[string]string{"X-Hub-Signature": "ab03955b9377f530aa298b1b6d273ae9a47e1e40"}, map[string]string{"X-Hub-Signature": "ab03955b9377f530aa298b1b6d273ae9a47e1e40"},
"application/json",
`{ `{
"head_commit":{ "head_commit":{
"added":[ "added":[
@ -571,7 +597,6 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
}, },
"ref":"refs/heads/master" "ref":"refs/heads/master"
}`, }`,
false,
http.StatusOK, http.StatusOK,
`arg: 1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb lolwut@noway.biz `arg: 1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb lolwut@noway.biz
env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00 env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
@ -583,6 +608,7 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
"missing-env-arg", // missing head_commit.timestamp "missing-env-arg", // missing head_commit.timestamp
"github", "github",
map[string]string{"X-Hub-Signature": "2cf8b878cb6b74a25090a140fa4a474be04b97fa"}, map[string]string{"X-Hub-Signature": "2cf8b878cb6b74a25090a140fa4a474be04b97fa"},
"application/json",
`{ `{
"head_commit":{ "head_commit":{
"added":[ "added":[
@ -611,7 +637,6 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
}, },
"ref":"refs/heads/master" "ref":"refs/heads/master"
}`, }`,
false,
http.StatusOK, http.StatusOK,
`arg: 1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb lolwut@noway.biz `arg: 1481a2de7b2a7d02428ad93446ab166be7793fbb lolwut@noway.biz
`, `,
@ -619,24 +644,24 @@ env: HOOK_head_commit.timestamp=2013-03-12T08:14:29-07:00
}, },
// test with custom return code // test with custom return code
{"empty payload", "github", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusBadRequest, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, ``}, {"empty payload", "github", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusBadRequest, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, ``},
// test with custom invalid http code, should default to 200 OK // test with custom invalid http code, should default to 200 OK
{"empty payload", "bitbucket", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusOK, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, ``}, {"empty payload", "bitbucket", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusOK, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, ``},
// test with no configured http return code, should default to 200 OK // test with no configured http return code, should default to 200 OK
{"empty payload", "gitlab", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusOK, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, ``}, {"empty payload", "gitlab", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusOK, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, ``},
// test capturing command output // test capturing command output
{"don't capture output on success by default", "capture-command-output-on-success-not-by-default", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusOK, ``, ``}, {"don't capture output on success by default", "capture-command-output-on-success-not-by-default", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusOK, ``, ``},
{"capture output on success with flag set", "capture-command-output-on-success-yes-with-flag", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusOK, `arg: exit=0 {"capture output on success with flag set", "capture-command-output-on-success-yes-with-flag", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusOK, `arg: exit=0
`, ``}, `, ``},
{"don't capture output on error by default", "capture-command-output-on-error-not-by-default", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusInternalServerError, `Error occurred while executing the hook's command. Please check your logs for more details.`, ``}, {"don't capture output on error by default", "capture-command-output-on-error-not-by-default", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusInternalServerError, `Error occurred while executing the hook's command. Please check your logs for more details.`, ``},
{"capture output on error with extra flag set", "capture-command-output-on-error-yes-with-extra-flag", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusInternalServerError, `arg: exit=1 {"capture output on error with extra flag set", "capture-command-output-on-error-yes-with-extra-flag", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusInternalServerError, `arg: exit=1
`, ``}, `, ``},
// Check logs // Check logs
{"static params should pass", "static-params-ok", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusOK, "arg: passed\n", `(?s)command output: arg: passed`}, {"static params should pass", "static-params-ok", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusOK, "arg: passed\n", `(?s)command output: arg: passed`},
{"command with space logs warning", "warn-on-space", nil, `{}`, false, http.StatusInternalServerError, "Error occurred while executing the hook's command. Please check your logs for more details.", `(?s)unable to locate command.*use 'pass[-]arguments[-]to[-]command' to specify args`}, {"command with space logs warning", "warn-on-space", nil, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusInternalServerError, "Error occurred while executing the hook's command. Please check your logs for more details.", `(?s)unable to locate command.*use 'pass[-]arguments[-]to[-]command' to specify args`},
{"unsupported content type error", "github", map[string]string{"Content-Type": "nonexistent/format"}, `{}`, false, http.StatusBadRequest, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, `(?s)error parsing body payload due to unsupported content type header:`}, {"unsupported content type error", "github", map[string]string{"Content-Type": "nonexistent/format"}, "application/json", `{}`, http.StatusBadRequest, `Hook rules were not satisfied.`, `(?s)error parsing body payload due to unsupported content type header:`},
} }
// buffer provides a concurrency-safe bytes.Buffer to tests above. // buffer provides a concurrency-safe bytes.Buffer to tests above.